The following unabridged reviews are made available under license from their respective rights holders and publishers. Reviews may be used for educational purposes consistent with the fair use doctrine in your jurisdiction, and may not be reproduced or repurposed without permission from the rights holders.

Note: This section may include reviews for related titles (e.g., same author, series, or related edition).

From Cooperative Children's Book Center (CCBC)

It’s never occurred to Wendy Toledo to wonder why her Salvadoran American dad and her Guatemalan mom, who’s been in the United States legally for years, are adamant about not making waves, but she’s taken the message to heart. So when Wendy and her friends start experiencing racist incidents at her new middle school, she downplays the impact of what’s happening, lying first and foremost to herself. She’s especially unwilling to seriously consider the possible involvement of Brett, a cute white boy who’s been flirting with her, and is excited when she and Brett are paired for a science project to build a telescope. At home, tensions are rising as her older brother, Tom, gets involved with protests in support of Luz, a Mexican woman who’s taken sanctuary from Immigrations and Customs Enforcement (ICE) in a nearby church. Wendy also finds old papers that prompt her to question the stories her parents have always told her about their pasts. When Wendy can no longer ignore Brett’s involvement in the increasing racist bullying, she’s frustrated when speaking out has little impact, at least at first. Meanwhile community outrage over both immigration and ICE is intensifying, leading to a terrifying incident that impacts Wendy and her family. This compelling, heartfelt story grounded by excellent characterizations delves into the complexity and messiness of human relationships on both an interpersonal and community scale and illuminates the powerful force that people working together for positive change can be. (Ages 10-13)

CCBC Choices 2024 © Cooperative Children's Book Center, Univ. of Wisconsin - Madison, 2024. Used with permission.

From Publisher's Weekly

Starred review from October 9, 2023
After U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement raids result in numerous neighbors’ deportations, Salvadoran-Guatemalan seventh grader Wendy Celestina Toledo and her family move from Melborn, S.C., to Columbus, Ohio. It’s a new start at a new school in a new city; Wendy’s parents’ number one rule is for Wendy and her older brother to keep their heads down. Still, Wendy is excited for her first day at Leopold Preparatory, a public school for gifted students, and the opportunity to enter the upcoming science fair. At school, she befriends artist Mal, student government hopeful K.K., and enthusiastic Etta, the daughter of the local pastor. Wendy’s family isn’t adjusting as well: her brother has been behaving recklessly, her mother rarely leaves the house, and both her parents feel uneasy about the woman taking sanctuary from ICE agents in the church next door, afraid that her situation will bring unwanted government attention to their home. When Wendy uncovers a family secret that could change everything, she must find the courage to stand up for what she believes in. Via a propulsive narrative that seamlessly balances typical tween worries with one girl’s social justice awakening, debut author Leahy crafts a powerful meditation on the difficult choice between what one views as right vs. safe with resounding empathy and skill. The supporting cast is racially diverse. Ages 8–12. Agent: Brent Taylor, Triada US.

From Booklist

October 1, 2023
Grades 4-7 Wendy Toledo would like nothing more than to reclaim a fraction of her own mental space, but every inch is filled with worries over being the new kid at school, experiencing casual racism, and potentially being detained by ICE, merely for being Latina. Unfortunately, some of her classmates are bullies, and neither the school's culture of fake equality nor the principal's own dismissive attitude helps to alleviate the toxicity. Wendy, for the most part, keeps it all in and focuses on completing her science-fair project. Even in one of the more severe instances of bullying, the seventh-grader observes from the sidelines, torn between the desire to stay safe and the urge to help. It takes an explosive family secret to rouse her out of her paralysis and finally make her stand up for herself and others. This theme of social activism dovetails with a brief exploration of how vulnerable people may refrain from participation. Leahy's debut, while at times heavy-handed, joins the growing list of fearless middle-grade fiction that trusts its readers' capacity for critical empathy.

COPYRIGHT(2023) Booklist, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

From Kirkus

September 1, 2023
Latine seventh grader Wendy Celestina Toledo loves outer space, but she's worried about things happening right here on Earth. After a U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement raid on her community leads to disappearances of several people she knows, including her best friend, Wendy and her Salvadoran-Guatemalan family move to a new neighborhood in Columbus, Ohio. Aspiring astronomer Wendy enters a school for gifted and talented students, makes a diverse group of new friends, and sets her sights on building a telescope and winning the science fair. However, with ICE vans patrolling the streets and a woman named Luz claiming sanctuary in the church down the street, her parents are fearful. Not only are Wendy and her friends enduring racist bullying at school, but someone Wendy loves is seriously threatened, and she must tap into her own inner resources to do what's right for herself and those she cares for. The stakes start out high but manage to continue to build throughout the story, culminating in an unexpected plot twist. Heavy topics like bullying, familial hardship, and academic pressures are explored in ways middle-grade readers will understand and are grounded in well-rounded characterization. Readers will resonate with the characters' three-dimensional personalities regardless of their and their families' own immigration experiences. A beautifully executed, character-driven tale of family, courage, resilience, and the meaning of what is right. (Fiction. 8-12)

COPYRIGHT(2023) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

From AudioFile Magazine

Almarie Guerra does a particularly good job of capturing the characters' feelings in this emotional story. She depicts Wendy's passion for science, as well as her reactions to her family's fear of friends disappearing because of ICE (Immigration and Customs Enforcement). Guerra projects the nasty tones of cruel teasing and racially based bullying at Wendy's school for gifted students, and these add to her depiction of Wendy's confusion about having been moved to a new school. Guerra's portrayal of Wendy's manipulative science partner is chilling, but there's warmth in female friends who rally around her. When family secrets are revealed, Guerra allows listeners to experience Wendy's shock, relief, and courage as she stands up for those who have been tormented. S.W. © AudioFile 2023, Portland, Maine